CAM CEO Sacha Roytman Dratwa
CAM CEO Sacha Roytman Dratwa

Australia’s Councils Must Not Be Bullied Out of Fighting Antisemitism

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

To Australia’s mayors, councillors and communities,

A campaign is urging Australian mayors and councillors to stay away from a summit on antisemitism. My message to those local leaders is simple: come anyway. Jewish Australians should not have to fight for a place on their own council’s agenda, least of all in Sydney, where families were attacked while gathering to light Chanukah candles.

Less than a year ago, 15 people were killed in an antisemitic terrorist attack at Bondi Beach. Earlier this month, Eva Geller, a 90-year-old Holocaust survivor wounded in the attack, died in hospital, bringing the death toll to 16. Australia gave survivors of the Holocaust a place to rebuild their lives. What does that promise mean today if their children and grandchildren cannot celebrate openly as Jews?

On 26 and 27 November, the Australian branch of the Combat Antisemitism Movement (CAM), together with Waverley Council, will host the Local Government Summit Against Antisemitism and for Social Cohesion in Sydney. CAM Australia works with local councils to address the challenges they face every day. What happens when a synagogue is targeted? When a Jewish family reports harassment, who answers? How do local leaders keep neighbours talking when tensions rise? David Gonski AC chairs the summit’s Australian advisory committee, whose members include Dr Ron Weiser AM, Charmaine Roth and Dr Orna Triguboff. They know their communities. They need no one abroad to tell them what is at stake.

Campaigners have circulated a template urging councillors to boycott the summit and advertised a rally against CAM. Peaceful protest is a right. So is criticism of Israel. But when a campaign recasts Australians working to protect Jewish neighbours as agents of a hidden “Zionist lobby,” what exactly is being alleged? That Jewish Australians cannot speak for themselves? That a councillor who takes antisemitism seriously must be taking orders from abroad? The idea of secret Jewish power is one of the oldest antisemitic conspiracy theories. Changing the vocabulary does not change what it is.

Some of the campaign materials point to my service in the Israel Defense Forces (IDF). I served in the IDF, and I have never hidden it. But if you want to know why I do this work, start in Belgium, where I grew up. My grandparents survived the Holocaust because people took the risk of hiding them. I witnessed antisemitism firsthand and saw what could happen when it was allowed to grow unchecked. I moved to Israel and watched the same hatred gain ground in Europe, the United States, Canada and elsewhere. Fighting it became my life’s work. It may start with the Jews. It never ends with us.

CAM supports the IHRA working definition of antisemitism because councils need a common language for recognising anti-Jewish hatred. The definition is non-legally binding and makes clear that criticism of Israel comparable to criticism of any other country is not antisemitic. Supporting Palestinian rights is not antisemitic. Blaming Jews collectively for Israel’s actions or accusing them of secretly controlling public institutions is.

I also want to say plainly what concerns me. To me, some of the rhetoric around this campaign echoes narratives I have seen promoted internationally by actors in Iran, Qatar, China and Russia. That resemblance is not evidence that any of those governments organised or paid for this campaign. I am asking Australian authorities to examine credible reports of intimidation against councillors, council staff and participants. If they find evidence of organised harassment or unlawful interference, they should establish who coordinated it, who financed it and whether anyone abroad played a role.

Australia’s response to Bondi cannot be to make Jewish life less visible or ask local leaders to keep their distance. That is why the summit will go ahead as planned. To the mayors and councillors deciding whether to attend: come, bring your questions, and do the work your communities elected you to do.

Sacha Roytman Dratwa
Chief Executive Officer, Combat Antisemitism Movement